Fast & affordable landlord insurance in New York
Landlord insurance in New York provides protection against rental property damage, liability claims, and lost rental income. Coverage and pricing vary based on property type and location. Get a quote for New York landlord insurance tailored to your rental.
We've gotten more than $55 million in property insured in New York
What to know about rental properties in New York
New York has one of the largest and most complex rental markets in the country. New York City alone has millions of renter-occupied units, and the rental market extends throughout the state — from the Hudson Valley and Long Island to Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, and Albany. About 46% of the state's households rent, and in New York City that figure exceeds 65%.
The sheer scale creates opportunities – and unique challenges. Over 2.2 million rental units operate within the five boroughs alone, while upstate markets collectively add another 1.5 million units to the statewide inventory. The demand for rental housing is as strong as it is anywhere in the country, but that doesn't mean New York is an easy state in which to operate a rental property.
For one, the barrier of entry is high; the median home price of $576,000 is top ten in the nation, and those prices skyrocket the closer you get to New York City. New York's landlord-tenant laws are also among the most tenant-friendly in the nation – particularly in the city, where rent stabilization, strict eviction protections, and the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 create a heavily regulated operating environment. (Upstate markets are somewhat more moderate.)
Weather risks include nor'easters, heavy snowfall, and ice storms. Being a northeast state near the Atlantic Ocean, New York can get hammered with extreme weather in the winter. All of this adds up to one of the highest risk-reward states in the country to operate a rental.
How landlord insurance works in New York
Landlord insurance in New York provides the dwelling, liability, and loss of rent coverage that rental property owners need. A homeowners policy won't cover properties you're renting out, regardless of whether you're operating in Manhattan or in a small upstate city. Standard homeowners policies explicitly exclude rental activities, and this exclusion applies universally.
Dwelling coverage needs to reflect rebuilding costs, which are significantly higher in the metro area than in other parts of the state.
Liability coverage is critical given the state's tenant-friendly legal environment — disputes, injury claims, and compliance issues can all generate substantial legal costs.
Loss of rent coverage protects cash flow during repair periods, reimbursing landlords for rental income they would have received if their property wasn't uninhabitable.
DP-1 vs DP-3 comparison for New York
Feature
DP-1
DP-3
Do you need landlord insurance in New York?
In a state where property values range from modest upstate homes to multi-million-dollar buildings in the city, the financial exposure of going uninsured varies — but it's significant at every level. New York's legal complexity, weather exposure, and high repair costs make landlord insurance a fundamental operating expense for any rental property owner in the state.
Consider the mathematics: a single liability judgment can exceed property values in many upstate markets, while dwelling replacement costs in prime NYC locations can reach seven figures even for modest buildings. The state's documented history of severe weather events, including Hurricane Sandy's $19 billion in statewide damages in 2012, demonstrates the concrete financial risks that make comprehensive coverage essential rather than optional for prudent New York property owners.
In short, you do need landlord insurance in New York, unless you're willing to roll the dice in an extreme way and possibly shoulder huge financial losses.
Average cost of landlord insurance in New York
New York's median landlord insurance premium is around $1,641.50 per year, though that number tells only part of the story in a state with as much geographic and market variation as New York.
New York City rental properties — particularly older urban buildings — underwrite very differently from upstate or suburban New York rentals. What you actually pay will depend on the property's age, construction, coverage limits, and – perhaps most importantly – location.
New York is a large state with incredibly diverse markets, from Manhattan high-rises to rural upstate properties, and premiums can vary dramatically even between neighboring boroughs or counties.
To get a quote on your rental property, all you need to do is enter your address and some other quick details below. Quotes are completely free and will be sent to your email within minutes.
Properties we look after
We make it easy to get landlord insurance for many types of properties
We also help AirBNBs, VRBOS, and other rental properties
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
Coverages
We cover a wide range of risks, or you can choose a limited set of coverages for a lower premium
Riot & civil commotion
Steadily’s landlord insurance covers property damage from riots and civil commotion — broken windows, structural fires, looted common areas — so the repair costs don’t fall entirely on you. Documentation connecting the damage to the civil unrest is required.
Vandalism & burglary
Steadily covers malicious damage to your rental from vandalism and break-ins — broken doors and windows, defaced surfaces, damaged fixtures and appliances. A police report is typically required to file the claim.
Loss of rent
When a covered event makes the unit temporarily uninhabitable, Steadily’s loss of rent coverage replaces the income you’d lose while repairs are underway — whether the cause is a fire, a burst pipe, or storm damage.
Storm and hail
Steadily covers storm and hail damage to the structure of your property — roof punctures, broken windows, wind-torn siding, fallen debris — as well as damage from extreme wind and tornadoes.
Water
For sudden water damage events such as burst pipes, plumbing failures and appliance overflow, Steadily covers the structural repairs and lost rental income if the unit can’t be occupied while the work is done. Flood damage from rising water requires a separate policy.
Legal liability
Landlord liability insurance pays medical bills, legal defense, and settlements when a tenant or visitor is injured at your rental and holds you responsible. It's built into every Steadily landlord policy in all 50 states with $300,000 to $2 million per occurrence, typically adding $200 to $400 a year to the bundled premium.
Fire
Steadily covers structural fire damage, smoke damage, personal property you own at the unit, and lost rental income while repairs are underway. That includes fires started in the kitchen, by the wiring, by a tenant, or by a wildfire nearby.
FAQs
about landlord insurance in
New York
Is landlord insurance required by law in New York?
New York doesn't have a state law requiring landlord insurance on rental properties. That said, lenders universally require it on financed properties, and the financial stakes in New York are high. Between elevated property values, the cost of construction and repairs, and a tenant-friendly legal environment, going without coverage leaves landlords exposed to potentially devastating losses.
Can a landlord require renters insurance in New York?
Yes. New York landlords are legally permitted to require tenants to carry renters insurance as a condition of the lease. This is common practice throughout the state, from New York City apartments to upstate single-family rentals. It creates a clear delineation of coverage responsibilities and reduces the likelihood of disputes after a loss.
Does landlord insurance cover loss of rental income in New York?
Most comprehensive landlord policies include loss of rent coverage, which reimburses you for missed rental income when a covered event makes the property uninhabitable. Given the high rental rates across much of New York — especially in the city and its suburbs — this coverage is particularly valuable. It typically continues until repairs are complete or a policy time limit (usually 12 months) is reached. It does not cover situations where a tenant simply stops paying.
Is landlord insurance tax deductible for New York property owners?
Yes. Landlord insurance premiums are fully deductible as a business expense on your federal return, reported on Schedule E. This applies to all coverage components — dwelling, liability, loss of rent, and endorsements. New York's high state income tax rates make tracking and maximizing every deductible rental expense especially worthwhile for landlords operating in the state.
Nearby cities
Get coverage in minutes
Competitive rates nationwide. Purpose-built for rental property investors.